對陳榮捷《朱子門人》一書之若干商議

Abstract

陳榮捷《朱子門人》一書，乃是研究朱子學派的重要參考資料，歷來學者頗多稱譽，此書亦影響了後來相關的作品，如《閩學源流》、《朱子學通論》等書。本文除了指出此書的五項優點外，如考證詳盡、揭示《朱子語類》體例、辯駁古人謬見等，亦提出八處缺失，如歸類錯誤、一人分置兩處、名字錯置等，針對陳氏所言，進行辯駁。另外，對於陳氏存疑、不解之處，本文亦試圖考察相關的材料，梳理部分問題，抑或推敲箇中的原因，如李孝述、章康、陳宓是否屬於朱門弟子、劉黼的籍貫為何、朱彝尊《經義考》何以列陳文蔚為傳《詩》、傳《禮》弟子等問題。因此，在本文中，主要從這三方面來進行論述，針對《朱子門人》一書，加以補充和釐清。

Chan Wing-tsit "朱子門人" is the important reference about the school of Zhu Xi thought.Many scholars applaude this book for research. The influence of This book "朱子門人" on other Neo-Confucianism research is self-evident. This article points five merits about this book, but it also proposed eight flaws. Moreover, This article will unravel some mystery that Chan Wing-tsit did not explain. Therefore, this paper mainly carries on the elaboration from three aspects.