東吳大學圖書館館藏支援法律系研究生學術研究之探討
Abstract
摘 要
本研究旨在應用引用文獻分析法,探討東吳大學法律系研究生進行學術研究時,其畢業論文之引用文獻特性,並利用書目核對法檢視館藏,以瞭解東吳大學圖書館館藏支援法律系研究生學術研究之供需程度。研究結果將提供作為東吳圖書館發展法律專業館藏之參考依據。本研究選取東吳大學法律系博碩士論文258篇,共蒐集34,306筆引用文獻,並分析其特性,包含引用之資料類型、引用之語文及引用之年代。
研究結果歸納如下:一、引用文獻之資料類型以圖書與期刊為主。二、引用文獻之語文特性,以中文為主,英文次之,日文、德文及法文的引用量,明顯偏低許多。三、引用文獻之出版時間以20年內出版的資料為主要需求。四、引用文獻仍以法律專書及法律期刊文獻為主,判例及法規條款雖有引用,但為數不多;「非法律資料」之引用率則占三分之一。五、東吳法律系博碩士論文引用文獻之資料來源,有91.5%來自紙本式文獻,數位式文獻僅占8.5%,表示東吳法律系研究生之學術研究主要還是倚重紙本式文獻。六、館藏支援程度方面,若以書名、作者、出版年皆符合之完全支援情況而言,館藏支援率為59.8%;若僅書名與作者符合及視為館藏支援的情況,則館藏支援率為67.1%。
根據研究結果,對東吳圖書館提出下列建議事項:1.加強充實館藏,以滿足教學與研究需求;2.善加利用館際合作資源;3.重視資訊服務;4.增訂法律期刊;5.建立館藏發展政策並定期評鑑;6.與學系合作加強推廣電子資源。
關鍵字: 館藏評鑑、館藏發展、館藏支援、引用文獻分析法、書目核對法。
ABSTRACT The purposes of this study were: (1) To investigate the characteristics of scholarly literature used by the graduate students of Department of Law of Soochow University for their theses. (2) To evaluate the satisfaction degree on how library collections support the graduate students research at the Department of Law of Soochow University. (3) The result of this study could be used to assist Soochow University Library in law collection development. The 258 theses studied generated a total of 34,306 citations. Types of materials cited, language and currency of literature were all analyzed. The results of this study indicated that: (1) Monographs and journal articles were cited mostly. (2) The majority of citations were to Chinese materials, English materials were cited less than Chinese. The citations in Japanese, Germany and French are obviously on the low side. (3) Generally speaking, materials published in 20 years were the main demand. (4) Law books and legal periodicals were the main demand. Case law and regulations were cited, but there were not amount to much. About one-third of the citations were “Non-legal materials”. (5) 91.5% of the citations were from printing materials, only 8.5% from the digital materials. It showed that the graduate students relied mostly on printing materials for their research. (6) The library could only provide 59.8% of the required collections under exact match; and could provide 67.1% of the required collections under partial match. Suggestions of improving services of Soochow University Library as follows: (1) To enrich the collection to fulfill the teaching and research needs of Soochow University. (2) To make good use of resources sharing through the “Interlibrary Loan” , which can make up for the shortage of collections . (3) To emphasize on iii information services to meet the research needs. (4)To increase in legal journal subscription. (5)A formal collection policy should be established in Soochow University Library. (6) To Coorperate with the Department of Law to promote the use of electronic resources.
ABSTRACT The purposes of this study were: (1) To investigate the characteristics of scholarly literature used by the graduate students of Department of Law of Soochow University for their theses. (2) To evaluate the satisfaction degree on how library collections support the graduate students research at the Department of Law of Soochow University. (3) The result of this study could be used to assist Soochow University Library in law collection development. The 258 theses studied generated a total of 34,306 citations. Types of materials cited, language and currency of literature were all analyzed. The results of this study indicated that: (1) Monographs and journal articles were cited mostly. (2) The majority of citations were to Chinese materials, English materials were cited less than Chinese. The citations in Japanese, Germany and French are obviously on the low side. (3) Generally speaking, materials published in 20 years were the main demand. (4) Law books and legal periodicals were the main demand. Case law and regulations were cited, but there were not amount to much. About one-third of the citations were “Non-legal materials”. (5) 91.5% of the citations were from printing materials, only 8.5% from the digital materials. It showed that the graduate students relied mostly on printing materials for their research. (6) The library could only provide 59.8% of the required collections under exact match; and could provide 67.1% of the required collections under partial match. Suggestions of improving services of Soochow University Library as follows: (1) To enrich the collection to fulfill the teaching and research needs of Soochow University. (2) To make good use of resources sharing through the “Interlibrary Loan” , which can make up for the shortage of collections . (3) To emphasize on iii information services to meet the research needs. (4)To increase in legal journal subscription. (5)A formal collection policy should be established in Soochow University Library. (6) To Coorperate with the Department of Law to promote the use of electronic resources.
Description
Keywords
館藏評鑑, 館藏發展, 館藏支援, 引用文獻分析法, 書目核對法, Collection Evaluation, Collection Development, Collection Support, Citation Checking, List Checking